Willows Of Shelbyville
2309 S Miller St, Shelbyville, IN 46176 · Capacity 121 · 3173989781
Nursing home Safety score 52/100
Willows Of Shelbyville holds a 2-of-5-star CMS rating (safety grade D).
CMS cost-report rate
From its public CMS cost report, Willows Of Shelbyville takes in an average of about $285 per resident-day across all payers — Medicare, Medicaid, and private pay combined. That is a facility-wide accounting average, not a private-pay quote, and it is not a monthly price: Medicare short-stay rehab is billed at a far higher daily rate than long-term custodial care, so the day-rate reflects payer mix as much as price.
Source: CMS Skilled Nursing Facility Cost Report (FY2023, data.cms.gov); facility record on CMS Care Compare. See our cost guide for what drives the number and what Medicare & Medicaid cover.
Why the safety grade is D
- CMS overall rating: 2 of 5 stars
- Health-inspection rating: 2 of 5 stars
- Staffing rating: 1 of 5 stars
The grade is computed by Senior Care Record Maps from this facility's public regulatory record — it is not assigned by any agency. Underlying data: CMS Care Compare / Medicare.gov (Jul 2026 snapshot) — verify every stat above on the CMS Care Compare page. Listed since 1967. How this grade is calculated → · ⚑ Report an error or dispute this record
See Willows Of Shelbyville on the map
Compare it against every other licensed facility in Shelbyville, filter by safety grade and price, and save it to your shortlist with Senior Care Record Maps.
Open in the map → All facilities in Shelbyville →Planning a visit? Take our free tour checklist and see what this level of care typically costs.
The full safety file on Willows Of Shelbyville
$19.99 one-time · lifetime accessThe grade and headline above are free. Senior Care Record Maps Pro opens this facility's complete record — every inspection, complaint and citation, plus advertised pricing — and lets you save it beside the alternatives you're weighing. No referral fees, no salespeople, your data never sold.
- This facility's full CMS deficiency, staffing & enforcement history
- Direct links to the underlying government records
- Save, tag & rate it against your other picks
- Side-by-side comparison & CSV shortlist export
One-time payment. Works on every facility in all 50 states, DC & territories.